2010 Music Reviews
Adore, Distorted Minds (2010) D
Techno-by-numbers, given away for free by Mr. Skramesto of Norway. It isn't painful to listen to, though the 90's did call and would like their samples back.
AFCGT, AFCGT (2010) D
I don't think the Sunn O))) guys need any help detuning their guitars or playing around with pedals and switches, thanks all the same.
Die Antwoord, $O$ (2010) D
"Aye aye aye I am your butterfly / I need your production / Yo, I'm a ninja." I can't tell if this hilariously cheesy "hip-hop" is intentionally awful or accidentally awful. If it wasn't getting perplexing critical raves, I'd say it was a novelty record.
Beach House, Teen Dream (2010) A
Gorgeous, ethereal pop from the Maryland-based duo of Alex Scally and Victoria Legrand - her delivery is sorrowful and searching and the keyboard work reminds me ever so much of the Velvet Underground. The lyrics (by Legrand) are ambiguously minimal and thoughtful (on "Zebra," for example: "Don't I know you better than the rest / All deception, all deception from you") and add an extra layer of poetry to the haunting compositions. This album was built on nostalgia and regret.
Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, Beat the Devil's Tattoo (2010) C
There are some entrancing moments in this, but they're lost between a lot of stale hooks and filler: after so many years and albums they still can't trim the proverbial fat like the Jesus and Mary Chain (though the masterful "Bad Blood" is their best track since "Love Burns"). If you're going to slit someone's throat, just make it a quick gesture; never deliberate.
Broken Social Scene, Forgiveness Rock Record (2010) C+
Just because there are a large number of contributors to this 'super group' doesn't necessarily mean their albums should be 'this' padded - it's clear with this one that they're trying to recapture the power of their admittedly stunning 2002 album "You Forgot It in People." Fitting, too, that this bloated exercise ends on the half-joking masturbatory ode "Me & My Hand."
Caribou, Swim (2010) B
Opening track "Odessa" is probably the best single he's produced - it's about being fed up with an abusive partner - but the album suffers from dubious vocal 'styling' - Mr. Snaith's instrumentation is top-notch but I'm a little mixed on the 'singing.' Then there are tracks like "Sun" and "Found Out" where I'm not sure what he was thinking.
Dangers, Messy, Isn't It? (2010) D
Outstanding: you boys know how to (a.) shout and (b.) hammer on the same chords ad nauseum. Now you just need some writing ability and decent songs and you're well on your way!
The Dillinger Escape Plan, Option Paralysis (2010) D+
Soft/loud stopping/starting: don't fans of the genre expect more? I'm going with not, since this formula's been keeping an inordinate number of mediocre bands unfortunately active for years. "We can never get back what we choose to throw away" ... so very true; once I delete this from my hard drive I'll never find it again. No major loss, there....
Bob Dylan, Bringing It All Back Home (1965) A
Famously caused a fervor at the time of its release because Bob had the audacity to use electric guitars for some of the tracks, which is clearly one of the more comically ridiculous 'outrages' of modern music. The tracklisting is basically a string of masterpieces, some minor, some timeless. The suggestions by a few people that he should be considered for the Nobel in Literature aren't so unrealistic ... you could argue Dylan has been one of the most important American poets of the last fifty years.
Fang Island, Fang Island (2010) C-
Adorable: a bunch of young rockers with severe attitudes (kind-of, sort-of) imitate arena rock, but without ever leaving their rec room! Listen to those chords they just threw out there ... great, huh, and how about that page they took from Vampire Weekend about getting those swirling keyboards in there, too ("Life Coach")? Be careful not to take too many sips of Dad's beer, okay?
Flying Lotus, Cosmogramma (2010) B
So it isn't "Los Angeles," but no one expected that. The Nintend-gimmicks find their due place next to the endless supply of sound effects - revving engines, a harp, handclaps, a tamborine, lasers firing. He has a few collaborators (Thom Yorke, Thundercat), but every track is distinctly his: he's a maximalist, but he makes it work.
Four Tet, There Is Love in You (2010) C
The bookends are excellent - the glitched-up "Angel Echoes" and tranquil "She Just Likes to Fight" - but everything in between strikes me as thoughtless filler. Kieran did a fantastic two-single release with Burial last year ("Moth/Wolf Cub") that showed he works well when collaborating, but when left alone he doesn't sound like he's challenging himself.
Girls, Album (2009) C+
I know his back story is great for journalists (parents in a cult, Mom-as-prostitute), but Chris Owens' whiny-voiced music strikes me as being disingenuous. Sometimes he gets it perfectly, though, which is what won this so many accolades: that sarcasm adds layers to something as simple as "Summertime" (the instrumental work on "Lauren Marie" is luscious).
Gonjasufi, A Sufi and a Killer (2010) C
Fuzzy-headed hip-hop needs a volume adjustment - he races through his two-plus minute tracks, but when it comes to the longer 'songs' they tend to become boorish (and Mr. Sufi tends to embellish his already crackily delivery).
Hot Chip, One Life Stand (2010) C-
As if the tacky synth dreck (the dated and ugly "Thieves in the Night") or repetitive dance dreck ("Hand Me Down Your Love") weren't enough to force one to skip ahead several tracks, then there's that ... ballad that just hits you in the face. Closes on a sweet note ("Take It In") after being largely misguided.
Robert Johnson, Red Hot Blues (The Blues Collection Vol. 6) (1994) A
I've apologized plenty of times for not caring much for B.B. King - sorry, Riley - and said I've always preferred the great Robert Johnson. Leaving that firestorm aside, this is an indispensible collection of Johnson's most important tracks, which have been covered numerous times by a variety of talent ... but have never been quite the same as Johnson's originals. It's music as catharsis: why does this horrible woman plague me so? why can't I get her out of my mind? why is my life so miserable? He knew he wasn't going to get answers, and there were (and are) no shortage of questions.
LCD Soundsystem, This Is Happening (2010) C+
What the hell happened? The equal amounts of biting humor and pathos in his earlier albums is missing: this is filled with too many petty ("Pow Pow," "Drunk Girls") or downright gauche ("I Can Change," the U2-esque "All I Want") tracks. "Dance Yrself Clean" has a bit of the old form, but it isn't enough. Has Mr. DFA gone completely L.A. in the worst possible way?
Little Boots, Hands (2010) B+
"New in Town" is Instant Top 40 Material - catchy, fun, painless - and so is "Stuck on Repeat," for that matter (and "Remedy" ... and "Mathematics"). I admit to being mixed on it before hearing it played on the overhead speaker at a Barnes and Noble - incidentally, while I was flipping through the latest Esquire - and found myself wondering why I didn't immediately fall for this disc the first time. Sometimes it takes listening to a record in an environment that isn't your bedroom - and one in which wearing pajamas and weeping profusely would be frowned upon - to truly appreciate it. This is a stellar pop album from a very young lady.
The Magnetic Fields, Realism (2010) B-
Merritt and His Loyal Team start this one with the eviscerating "You Must Be Out of Your Mind," which is the exact opposite of what you'd have put on an "I Love You" mixtape (back when crazy romantics did such thing ... so 20th century). Yet that wit can be overbearing at times, and bouncy sarcasm should only be used sparingly ("We Are Having a Hootenanny").
Massive Attack, Heligoland (2010) D+
They're back to two of their original three members (Del Naja and Marshall) but they're still not making anything close to the brilliance of their early work, or even "Mezzanine." Even the dull Horace Andy collaboration "Splitting the Atom" would have been scrapped years ago. The closest to 'elegance' they achieve is with Hope Sandoval providing the lyrics for "Paradise Circus," with its cinematic strings and handclaps. Did someone lose Liz Fraser's phone number?
MGMT, Congratulations (2010) C+
It's half a really good album. "It's Working" adds a modern twist on the kaleidoscopes, incense and peppermint of the late '60s/early '70s (for whatever reason, I can picture Peter Sellers dancing in the music video for it) and the glorious "I Found a Whistle" could theoretically put the duo back on "Yo Gabba Gabba" (art is everywhere, kids), though after the odd "Siberian Breaks" it just turns into effects ("Lady Dada's Nightmare") and half-hearted pop ("Congratulation").
The National, High Violet (2010) C
See, there's a fine line between being slightly remorseful and tastefully sad but these guys are outright maudlin (and not even in that great Addison DeWitt way!), sometimes hitting hard (the endless declaration in "Sorrow" that "I don't want to get over you"), but then keeping on that same downbeat tone for the entire album. They're trying desperately to sock you emotionally, and the sweat stains are showing and growing. Your dog doesn't die every day. You didn't just wake up. You don't lose a lover every hour. At least Interpol turned up the reverb and sarcasm....
Owen Pallett, Heartland (2010) C-
He drops the "Final Fantasy" moniker because of legal issues and ramps up the theatrical in this apparent put-down of the United States ("I will not sing your praises") ... trouble is, this young-ish Canadian can't cut as deep as, oh, Randy Newman. Like Andrew Bird, his music still strikes me precious and preening - a musician quite taken with his own production skills (and not so much with his songwriting).
Pantha du Prince, Black Noise (2010) C-
Not enough diversity to separate this from the rest of the minimal trance guys - The Field in particular does considerably more for the senses with considerably less, stripping away while Mr. Weber clutters with distractions. I'm sure we all know how innovative dropping silverware over a generic beat can be....
Pharoah Sanders, Love in Us All (1974) B+
"To John" is a little too scattered for me, but "Love Is Everywhere" is so unbelievably inspiring (... and slightly mad) I can't believe it took me this many years of listening to jazz to stumble upon it (via YouTube no less!).
S, I'm Not as Good at It as You (2010) C-
From the Tori Amos/Polly Scattergood School of Women with Uncureable Problems comes this offering from Jenn Ghetto, who pleads with you to save her, insists she can save you and gets around to admitting she's being difficult. Maybe if you stopped dating alcoholics and cocaine addicts things would pick up for you. Then you can write an album about things other than your issues. You're quite welcome. Signed, Dr. Matt.
Sightings, City of Straw (2010) C
Clickety-clickety-fuzz-fuzz. Brooklyn-based three-piece try to revive memories of Albini's Big Black project crossed with Naked City crossed with DNA crossed with static-y static, but this is a rather paltry offering and quickly forgettable.
Sleigh Bells, Treats (2010) B
Has much more in common with Top 40 radio than anyone would probably be willing to admit (it released rather high on the Billboard charts): the heavy production, the hooks, Alexis Krauss' sweet voice. Dumb bunny lyrics can be ignored when the instruments are jacked up to 12 and your teeth are clenched ("Crown on the Ground").
Spoon, Transference (2010) B
Hallelujah, it's their best since 2001's "Girls Can Tell," I think. Britt Daniel spits out clumps of thoughts while his trusty bandmates hammer out the catchy backgrounds. They can get repetitious and tedious (the interminable "Mystery Zone," "Who Makes Your Money?"), however, but that's the price you pay for the good stuff ("Before Destruction," "Nobody Gets Me But You").
The Strange Boys, Be Brave (2010) B-
Creaky voiced lead singer Ryan Sambol mopes over '60s jangle pop ... and it's pretty frickin' good. Takes multiple listens to get around the whiny vocal stylings, which are best described as a drunk mocking Caleb Followill during karaoke hour - what remains are solid songs and some smart lyrics: when he's advising everyone to be strong, he's really trying to convince himself. I can get behind that.
The Tallest Man on Earth, The Wild Hunt (2010) B+
Is it just me or is 2010 the year for polarizing lead singers? Swede Kristian Matsson's Dylan-inspired voice is his second best instrument, actually: these are ten wonderfully written and deeply contemplated folk songs. If you're telling me how unhappy you are, you better be smart about it.
These New Puritans, Hidden (2010) C+
They claim to be making music that's "dancehall meets Steve Reich" ... so in other words they're trying for Underworld? I guess the influence is there, but the result is half-baked: they think repeating things over and over again make the songs more memorable, but they're end up just being obnoxious ("Attack Music," "We Want War"). Underworld wanted to replicate the feeling of being high and happy and alive; these songs drag to their droll conclusion (with the exception of the glorious, druggy "White Chords").
Titus Andronicus, The Monitor (2010) B
The best band in existence named after a work by Shakespeare! Has the feel and spunk of a bar band, but there's an artistry that they have tucked in there: there are references to America's wartime troubles, but it's also about drinking and drinking and drinking to forget. Now if only someone would have cut off their hands before they allowed "The Battle of Hampton Roads" to go over fourteen minutes....
Vampire Weekend, Contra (2010) B-
It isn't nearly up to the standard of their masterful debut, but it's not like these Columbia kids don't know that. It plays it safe, rehashing Paul Simonisms and dragging out what would have been B-sides on their first LP ("Horchata," "Cousins") before concluding on a beautifully mixed-up note (the cutting "I Think Ur a Contra") that gives hint of what they're capable of ... once they strip their songs down and climb out of their post-collegiate malaise.
The xx, xx (2009) B
When they say 'minimal' they mean it: when the guitar sneaks in on the excellent "Basic Space" it comes as a surprise ... and elevates that song to another wistful level. Not everything else is as finely balanced as "Basic Space," however, and the album has some dead spots ... before the desperate sultriness seeps back into it.
Yellow Swans, Going Places (2010) D+
They turn out the fuzz and static until their neighbors threaten to call the cops; they'd put more thought into it, but thinking is for people "inside the box," dude. I have "heard" Merzbow, good sirs, and neither of you are Merzbow.
Singles of the Year: Beach House: "Walk in the Park," Black Rebel Motorcycle Club: "Bad Blood," Caribou: "Odessa," Four Tet: "She Just Likes to Fight," LCD Soundsystem: "Dance Yrself Clean," Little Boots: "New in Town," The Magnetic Fields: "You Must Be Out of Your Mind," S: "Wait," Sleigh Bells: "Rill Rill," Spoon: "Written in Reverse," Strange Boys: "You Can't Only Love When You Want To," These New Puritans: "White Chords," The Tallest Man on Earth: "You're Going Back," Vampire Weekend: "I Think Ur a Contra"
Back